South Stands Denver on Facebook South Stands Denver on Linkedin South Stands Denver on Twitter South Stands Denver on Google+

Is Colorado Springs too crappy even for the crappy Rockies?

Is Colorado Springs too crappy even for the crappy Rockies?

"Once vibrant, downtown Colorado Springs is a sad wasteland now. Development has been pushed east and the heart of the city has been left to wither." Read More ...

Radio Row: Denver fans clamor for Clough

Radio Row: Denver fans clamor for Clough

"Now that Broncos’ season is in full swing there is a appreciable chasm in Denver sports talk radio. " Read More ...

How not to get bitten by daily fantasy sports

How not to get bitten by daily fantasy sports

"First of all, realize that the inevitable 100% deposit bonus you'll be taking advantage of is the equivalent of that first line of coke you sniffed at the kegger. It’s...

Denver Does Dallas: the great “illness” mystery of pre-season week four

Denver Does Dallas: the great “illness” mystery of pre-season week four

"This synopsis of what I think might have happened is completely bereft of established fact and is no way intended to be seen as a news story. It’s entirely speculative." Read...

Here’s Your Broncos / Colts Tweetrospective™, the entire game retold in Tweets

Here’s Your Broncos / Colts Tweetrospective™, the entire game retold in Tweets

Football season is finally here and the Broncos’ first game has come and gone. It was a doozy - especially in the first half - and, as always, it was...

If the Broncos win the Super Bowl I will drink my pee.

If the Broncos win the Super Bowl I will drink my pee.

"I'll drink eight ounces. That's all. The secretion will be collected in the men's room of whatever facility I happen to be at, under moderate supervision, into a rocks glass...

High expectations mean spoiled fans in Broncos Country

High expectations mean spoiled fans in Broncos Country

"Unlike in the Elway years we failed to watch the Broncos with wide-eyed amazement. Instead we anticipated victories and felt vindicated when they came. That's why the loss in the...

Radio Row INTERVIEW: Peter Burns scored his dream gig but the Press Box will remain in good hands

Radio Row INTERVIEW: Peter Burns scored his dream gig but the Press Box will remain in good hands

"The Press Box is my baby." Burns told me. "I am not looking forward to leaving it but I know it's in good hands." Read More ...

Dusty Saunders takes Drew Soicher to task at long last

Dusty Saunders takes Drew Soicher to task at long last

"9 News employs dozens of excellent reporters and anchors who help the station set the gold standard with its local news product. Even its other sports anchors, Rod Mackey, Aaron...

The de-Masaiing of the Nuggets has begun

The de-Masaiing of the Nuggets has begun

When Masai Ujiri remained the GM of your Denver Nuggets he was held in very high regard as one of the NBA's finest wheeler-dealers. In his absence, though, some of...

Change nothing but change the name Redskins

Change nothing but change the name Redskins

"Once Daniel Snyder capitulates the matter will be swept beneath the rug within a week and our attention will be drawn elsewhere. That's the way these things work." Read more ...

Will we look back more fondly on the Tebow season than on the Manning era?

Will we look back more fondly on the Tebow season than on the Manning era?

If Peyton Manning never wins a Super Bowl with the Broncos it's quite possible that decades from now fans will look back with greater fondness on the 2011 season than...

Better grilling NOW with Mangrate, the grill enhancement system. Use promo code: Denver for a $10 discount

Better grilling NOW with Mangrate, the grill enhancement system. Use promo code: Denver for a $10 discount

We at South Stands have been using Mangrate (http://www.mangrate.com/) for years. What's Mangrate? It's the 100% made in America grill enhancement system consisting of solid cast iron grill grates just like...

Dear John: a face-painting fanatical Broncos fan confronts Reidy's disgust

Dear John: a face-painting fanatical Broncos fan confronts Reidy's disgust

The host of the South Stands Denver Fancast, our own John Reidy (@johnreidydenver), has been vocal in his digust for the Broncos since their disasterous performance in the Super Bowl....

«
»
Saturday, 10 November 2012 11:17

Fantasy Falderal (TM): revisiting the first-round QB debate

Written by 
Rate this item
(0 votes)

Prior to the fantasy football season various drafting experts provided players with differing advice on first-round strategy, particulary where quarteback were concerned. As we head toward the fantasy playoffs, let's revisit the issue.

Read more

Prior to 2012 fantasy drafts, two ESPN fantasy experts had two different perspectives on early draft strategy. Matthew Berry, AKA the "Talented Mr. Roto" endorsed snagging a top-5 QB, Cecil Lammey, NFL Insider and FootballGuys.com analyst, promoted what he called "stud running back theory".

Three weeks into the fantasy season, the question of whether or not to draft a premium QB with an early pick in the first round of drafts seemed to have been answered "No" . At that time I wrote a Fantasy Falderal item for this site titled "The first-round QB debate is settled". Top-teir QBs had gotten off to a slow start. On the flip side, top-5 backs were proving their worth. So, it seemed as though the issue was resolved. As fantasy players gear up for the playoffs, though, there's less clarity on the matter.

For the sake of reflection let's look at the performances of Aaron Rodgers, Drew Brees, Tom Brady and Matthew Stafford, the four QBs thought to be potentially worthy of a top-12 overall selection, versus Arian Foster, Ray Rice, LeShean McCoy and Chris Johnson, the consensus top four RBs.

How do these two groups compare in terms of reliability and overall scoring?

For reference I am using the South Stands Denver Fantasy Football League (SSDFFL) in which passing TDs are worth 5 points and rushing TDs are worth 6. This is a PPR league. Fractional scoring is allowed, but I will round point totals off for this article.

In that league Aaron Rodgers is the top overall player with 347 points. Brees is the second scorer with 345 points. Brady is fourth with 321 points and Stafford is seventh with 286 points. The top four pre-draft QBs have produced an average of about 325 points each.

In this league, Peyton Manning, Matt Ryan, Andrew Luck and Carson Palmer are all near the top of the scoring heap, also, having produced an average of 302 points. Robert Griffin III falls just outside this group becuase there is no premium on QB rushing yardage. Of this group, only Matt Ryan was widely considered to be a top-10 "lock". The others are all round 5-6 type selections or, in Palmer's case, a late round flier, yet the group has produced almost 90% of the points the top-4 QB selections have.

The stud RBs, Foster, Rice McCoy and Johnson, are all amongst the top ten RBs in scoring after nine games, having produced an average of 124.5 points. A number of surprise performers have also cracked the top ten, however. Adrian Peterson, Doug Martin, Trent Richardson and Marshawn Lynch, all considered high-upside plays prior to the draft, have averaged 132.5 in accumulated points. Of this group only Doug Martin was likely to have slipped past the second round in drafts. Still, Martin, along with players like CJ Spiller, Willis McGahee and Alfred Morris are examples of guys that could be doing very well for fantasy players that did opt to select an early QB.

After week three I had come around to the idea that Cecil Lammey's "stud RB theory" was nails. I am beginning to waiver now. Part of this is because Drew Brees, Aaron Rodgers and Tom Brady have slowly risen back to the top eschelon of fantasy performers. Each started out slowly, but has proven to be a safe investment as the season has gone by. Guys like RGIII and Andrew Luck have been nice surprises, but it's clear that the QBs selected in the first round have lived up to expectations. There is a pretty big dropoff for QB production between the top six 2012 QBs and the next grouping.

The dropoff at RB occurs after the top five, two of whom, Doug Martin and Trent Richardson, could have been drafted as late as the third round in some 12-team leagues.

It's tough to question the validity of drafting a QB early. What has become abundantly clear, however, is that drafting WR is the first round has not worked out. Calvin Johnson, the traditional RD1 WR has been an enormous disappointment.

 

 

 

 

 

Last modified on Saturday, 10 November 2012 12:24
Colin Daniels

Colin is the emcee of the South Stands Denver Fancast and maintains our Twitter and Facebook accounts.

Best of Westword 2013: Best Blog
Best of Westword 2011: Best Podcast
Subscribe to South Stands Denver Fancast on iTunes

South Stands Denver Fancast Playlist

SSDF Podcast

  • FantasyVille episode 1.4
    We talk bad beats and beat downs by the Atlanta Falcons. Previews of this week's matchups and plenty of Daily…
  • FantasyVille episode 1.3
    We talk about the unpredictability of fantasy football and especially Thursday night games. Good matchups, and what experts we listen…
  • FantasyVille episode 1.2
    It's FantasyVille numero 2 folks. Your source for all things fantasy lifestyle. We answer questions, do some previews but mainly…
  • FantasyVille episode 1.1
    Episode one of the FantasyVille podcast featuring "Captain Fantasy" @scottstafford who dispenses his fantasy knowledge like a ladel from a…

SSDF on Facebook

SSDF Twitter Watch

SSDF Authors