South Stands Denver on Facebook South Stands Denver on Linkedin South Stands Denver on Twitter South Stands Denver on Google+

Godspeed, Adrian Dater. Godspeed.

Godspeed, Adrian Dater. Godspeed.

"Well, the communications must have been real. She was, if her Twitter account was to be believed, quite upset with Dater for his actions and she launched a personal campaign...

Is “Super Creepy” Adrian Dater posing more problems for the Post?

Is “Super Creepy” Adrian Dater posing more problems for the Post?

"Deadspin has once again become interested in Dater’s exploits on Twitter. This time the site was contacted by a female hockey fan who provided screen grabs of some rather creepy...

Pro leagues / teams are making deals with the Devil in daily fantasy sports

Pro leagues / teams are making deals with the Devil in daily fantasy sports

"The industry has cleverly slipped into the loopholes left in the gaming act and in doing so has essentially replaced online poker as the most popular form of internet gambling." CLICK...

A stunning Broncos loss has made us normal people again

A stunning Broncos loss has made us normal people again

"Better now than later, I say. Better for the fans. Better for the team. Not only do the Broncos now have a better perspective on how they might be beaten...

Radio Row: Survey says solo Sandy, lop off Lundy at the Fan

Radio Row: Survey says solo Sandy, lop off Lundy at the Fan

"The newest changes in Denver Sports talk radio are coming to 104.3 the Fan and would seem to have been precipitated by the results of a survey the station...

The Broncos' slow starts are nothing to dismiss

The Broncos' slow starts are nothing to dismiss

In fact, this wasn’t the first time one might’ve watched the beginning of a Broncos game and wondered what the hell is wrong with Manning? click the read more link...

The other half of Broncos Country

The other half of Broncos Country

"...ultimately, what we saw at Gillette Stadium was a team that still isn’t going anywhere if Manning isn’t playing at an elite level." click the read more link below ...

Champ must retire a Bronco

Champ must retire a Bronco

We're not normally the pomp and circumstance types around here but on this issue we agree - Champ Bailey, who announced his retirement from the NFL today despite "interest from...

Into the Fogg: Should Josh McDaniels get credit for the current Broncos success?

Into the Fogg: Should Josh McDaniels get credit for the current Broncos success?

"McDaniels, for all his glaring faults, realized that Cutler would never amount to the quarterback we all expected him to be when Denver moved up to draft him in the...

Mark Rycroft can actually make you a smarter hockey fan

Mark Rycroft can actually make you a smarter hockey fan

"Kudos to the Colorado Avalanche. In a world where more and more professional teams are turning to their broadcast crew to further their own public relations department’s agenda, it’s fantastic...

«
»
Saturday, 10 November 2012 11:17

Fantasy Falderal (TM): revisiting the first-round QB debate

Written by 
Rate this item
(0 votes)

Prior to the fantasy football season various drafting experts provided players with differing advice on first-round strategy, particulary where quarteback were concerned. As we head toward the fantasy playoffs, let's revisit the issue.

Read more

Prior to 2012 fantasy drafts, two ESPN fantasy experts had two different perspectives on early draft strategy. Matthew Berry, AKA the "Talented Mr. Roto" endorsed snagging a top-5 QB, Cecil Lammey, NFL Insider and FootballGuys.com analyst, promoted what he called "stud running back theory".

Three weeks into the fantasy season, the question of whether or not to draft a premium QB with an early pick in the first round of drafts seemed to have been answered "No" . At that time I wrote a Fantasy Falderal item for this site titled "The first-round QB debate is settled". Top-teir QBs had gotten off to a slow start. On the flip side, top-5 backs were proving their worth. So, it seemed as though the issue was resolved. As fantasy players gear up for the playoffs, though, there's less clarity on the matter.

For the sake of reflection let's look at the performances of Aaron Rodgers, Drew Brees, Tom Brady and Matthew Stafford, the four QBs thought to be potentially worthy of a top-12 overall selection, versus Arian Foster, Ray Rice, LeShean McCoy and Chris Johnson, the consensus top four RBs.

How do these two groups compare in terms of reliability and overall scoring?

For reference I am using the South Stands Denver Fantasy Football League (SSDFFL) in which passing TDs are worth 5 points and rushing TDs are worth 6. This is a PPR league. Fractional scoring is allowed, but I will round point totals off for this article.

In that league Aaron Rodgers is the top overall player with 347 points. Brees is the second scorer with 345 points. Brady is fourth with 321 points and Stafford is seventh with 286 points. The top four pre-draft QBs have produced an average of about 325 points each.

In this league, Peyton Manning, Matt Ryan, Andrew Luck and Carson Palmer are all near the top of the scoring heap, also, having produced an average of 302 points. Robert Griffin III falls just outside this group becuase there is no premium on QB rushing yardage. Of this group, only Matt Ryan was widely considered to be a top-10 "lock". The others are all round 5-6 type selections or, in Palmer's case, a late round flier, yet the group has produced almost 90% of the points the top-4 QB selections have.

The stud RBs, Foster, Rice McCoy and Johnson, are all amongst the top ten RBs in scoring after nine games, having produced an average of 124.5 points. A number of surprise performers have also cracked the top ten, however. Adrian Peterson, Doug Martin, Trent Richardson and Marshawn Lynch, all considered high-upside plays prior to the draft, have averaged 132.5 in accumulated points. Of this group only Doug Martin was likely to have slipped past the second round in drafts. Still, Martin, along with players like CJ Spiller, Willis McGahee and Alfred Morris are examples of guys that could be doing very well for fantasy players that did opt to select an early QB.

After week three I had come around to the idea that Cecil Lammey's "stud RB theory" was nails. I am beginning to waiver now. Part of this is because Drew Brees, Aaron Rodgers and Tom Brady have slowly risen back to the top eschelon of fantasy performers. Each started out slowly, but has proven to be a safe investment as the season has gone by. Guys like RGIII and Andrew Luck have been nice surprises, but it's clear that the QBs selected in the first round have lived up to expectations. There is a pretty big dropoff for QB production between the top six 2012 QBs and the next grouping.

The dropoff at RB occurs after the top five, two of whom, Doug Martin and Trent Richardson, could have been drafted as late as the third round in some 12-team leagues.

It's tough to question the validity of drafting a QB early. What has become abundantly clear, however, is that drafting WR is the first round has not worked out. Calvin Johnson, the traditional RD1 WR has been an enormous disappointment.

 

 

 

 

 

Last modified on Saturday, 10 November 2012 12:24
Colin Daniels

Colin is the emcee of the South Stands Denver Fancast and maintains our Twitter and Facebook accounts.

Best of Westword 2013: Best Blog
Best of Westword 2011: Best Podcast
Subscribe to South Stands Denver Fancast on iTunes

South Stands Denver Fancast Playlist

SSDF Podcast

  • South Stands Denver Fancast, Show 202: Tom Nalen gets in the bunker
    Denver Broncos legend, Ring of Famer and all around cool dude, Tom Nalen joins us again for a rousing South…
  • South Stands Denver Fancast, Show 201
    Where do we begin? How about the beginning. Long time friend of the show, ESPN Denver and FootballGuys.com's Cecil Lammey…
  • South Stands Denver Fancast, Show 200
    Show 200. We started as the McDaniels era was getting under way and we out lasted that bastard. What a…
  • FantasyVille, Episode 1.9
    Welcome back to FantasyVille! Unpack your bags, stay awhile and talk some fantasy football with your hosts Colin Daniels and…

SSDF on Facebook

SSDF Twitter Watch